We finally got to watch former Vice-President Gore's "documentary" on global warming - saw it on DVD last week.
Certainly, if you like Al Gore you will LOVE this movie. Between a third and 40% of it is about him, with the rest dedicated to the topic. This biographical and promotional material is spread throughout the movie
You learn all about Al Gore. All about his childhood, his father's farm (his father was also a Senator from Tennessee),the sister who died of lung cancer, his son who was badly injured when hit by a car, and his early career.
There's a section of the film devoted to the contested 2000 Presidential election where he lost to Bush, with the disputed vote count in Florida, despite winning the national popular vote.
And you get to see a couple of dozen close-ups of Al Gore. Mostly thinking deep thoughts. Head shots with him looking pensive, or meditative, or deep in thought. Or hustling through an airport to get where he has to get to give his Global Warming slide show (Gore states in the film that he's given it over a thousand times, throughout the U.S. and many other countries.)
He is presented as an early apostle/prophet of enviornmentalism and Saving the Planet from Global Warming.
The non-Gore promotional sections of the movie is a well-done presentation by Gore of what he calls his "slide show" (actually a powerpoint presentation). This portion of An Inconvenient Truth starts with and has as it's foundation the presumption that Global Warming is real AND it is unquestionably caused by carbon dioxide build-up in the atmosphere, due to human activity. This is not proven by any means in the documentary; it is simply presumed, as if any other explanation(s) simply aren't credible.
In marketing, this approach is referred to as "the assumed sale."
No question, there are some powerful images - for my money the most powerful being the pictures of glaciers fifty or one hundred years ago, (for example on Mount Killimanjaro) and the same glaciers today, in some cases showing retreats of miles.
There are also interesting graphs aiming to show a relationship between the rise in carbon dioxide levels and a rise in temperature.
But much of the science is scatty and goes way over the top. For example Gore states that a rise of 5 degrees in the future (he doesn't exactly specify the time frame) is on the low end of scientific estimates. Wrong! the recently released UN report on climate change says that if things continue as they are, by 2100 the temperature will have risen about 1 degree centigrade (or 2.1 degrees fahrenheit). Tom Faranda's Folly: Global Warming Update #7 - the UN report
Mr. Gore warns that there is an imminent danger of a 20 foot rise in sea levels; he shows aerial pictures of lower Manhattan and then does some computer-generated modelling to show how the World Trade Center site will be underwater. But the UN report (you really should hit the link above and then read the report!) suggests a rise of only 17 inches by the year 2100.
Other pending calamities: a reversal of several of the great ocean currents - an increase in the number and severity of hurricanes - catastrophic changes in rainfall patterns ... Could go on but you get the point.
At the end of An Inconvenient Truth Mr. Gore makes an impassioned call to action to his audience (the mostly adoring people at the slide show). "you can make a difference... you can turn this around..." etc, etc.
but as has been revealed recently by several newspaper investigations, Mr. Gore talks the talk, but he doesn't walk the walk. He leads a life of opulent energy consumption while living in a mansion that would be the envy of Louis XIV. If you want to read about it, go here.Tom Faranda's Folly: Global Warming Update #10
So for myself, you'll just have to label me a carbon dioxide "skeptic." I love the outdoors and nature, we re-cycle and pay a bit more for our electricity by being in the con ed water power and wind power program, and we generally live pretty modestly.
But the world has more important concerns then whether the Greenland glaciers will melt by the end of the third millenium (it's in the UN report- Tom Faranda's Folly: Global Warming Update #7 - the UN report )
Recent Comments