Nicolas Kristoff is an uber-liberal columnist for the NY Times, but unlike most uber-liberals, he doesn't just talk the talk, he walks the walk. He's spoken out and travelled to Darfur, worked to end child slavery, and child prostitution, and campaigned on other human rights issues, especially in Africa.
And he's an honest guy. So honest that this past Sunday he wrote a column castigating self-identifying Liberals for their poor support of charities.
Op-Ed Columnist - Bleeding Heart Tightwads - NYTimes.com
The problem is this: We liberals are personally stingy.
Liberals show tremendous compassion in pushing for generous government spending to help the neediest people at home and abroad. Yet when it comes to individual contributions to charitable causes, liberals are cheapskates.
Arthur Brooks, the author of a book on donors to charity, “Who Really Cares,” cites data that households headed by conservatives give 30 percent more to charity than households headed by liberals. A study by Google found an even greater disproportion: average annual contributions reported by conservatives were almost double those of liberals.
Other research has reached similar conclusions. The “generosity index” from the Catalogue for Philanthropy typically finds that red states are the most likely to give to nonprofits, while Northeastern states are least likely to do so.
I am familiar with Brooks' work - he's written several columns in a variety of publications - here's a posting I did on one of them Are Americans stingy or generous? - as well as the Massachusetts-based Generosity Index. The Index was established a few years ago to study why people in Massachusetts are so stingy - typically one of the very bottom states in terms of per capita charitable giving. The Generosity Index gets their data from public information at the IRS on charitable giving. The last time I looked, Mississippi was ranked #1 on per capita charitable giving and New Hampshire was #50. Massachusetts was #49. New York was dead, smack in the middle, at #25. Remember, this is per capita giving, based on percentage of income given to charity.
Americans give sums to charity equivalent to 1.67 percent of G.N.P., according to a terrific new book, “Philanthrocapitalism,” by Matthew Bishop and Michael Green. The British are second, with 0.73 percent, while the stingiest people on the list are the French, at 0.14 percent.
(Looking away from politics, there’s evidence that one of the most generous groups in America is gays. Researchers believe that is because they are less likely to have rapacious heirs pushing to keep wealth in the family.)
>>>>>>
It’s true that religion is the essential reason conservatives give more, and religious liberals are as generous as religious conservatives. Among the stingiest of the stingy are secular conservatives.
According to Google’s figures, if donations to all religious organizations are excluded, liberals give slightly more to charity than conservatives do. But Mr. Brooks says that if measuring by the percentage of income given, conservatives are more generous than liberals even to secular causes.
In any case, if conservative donations often end up building extravagant churches, liberal donations frequently sustain art museums, symphonies, schools and universities that cater to the well-off. (It’s great to support the arts and education, but they’re not the same as charity for the needy. And some research suggests that donations to education actually increase inequality because they go mostly to elite institutions attended by the wealthy.)
Conservatives also appear to be more generous than liberals in nonfinancial ways. People in red states are considerably more likely to volunteer for good causes, and conservatives give blood more often. If liberals and moderates gave blood as often as conservatives, Mr. Brooks said, the American blood supply would increase by 45 percent.
So, does Liberalism = "Do as I say, not as I do?"
Well it's certainly true in the case of our Vice-president elect, Joe Biden. Remember "Patriotic duty" to pay high taxes? But not with his money - over the past ten years his total family income was over $2.5 million and his charitbale donations totalled $3690. VP nominee Joe Biden releases ten years of tax returns, showing he gives virtually nothing to charity.
How does he look himself in the mirror?
Recent Comments