In the past weekend's Wall Street Journal.
The Gosnell Trial - for eight murders - somehow overlooked by most of the media, since Gosnell is an abortionist
Well worth reading the entire essay, which only takes a few minutes.
Leon Kass: The Meaning of the Gosnell Trial
Eminent bioethicist Leon Kass on the dangers of a world increasingly indifferent to matters of human dignity.
The trial of Kermit Gosnell—a Philadelphia doctor charged in January
2011 with, among other things, murdering seven infants who survived
abortions he performed—has been under way for a month. But it was only
last week that the case was thrust into the national spotlight. Thanks
to intense pressure from conservative critics of the media's apparent
lack of interest in the case, the rest of the country has now glimpsed
some of what went on for years in Gosnell's benignly named Women's
Medical Society.
Investigators who raided the clinic in 2010 saw "blood on the floor"
and smelled "urine in the air," according to the grand jury that
indicted Gosnell. They also found "fetal remains haphazardly stored
throughout the clinic—in bags, milk jugs, orange-juice cartons, and even
in cat-food containers." Members of Gosnell's staff testified that the
abortionist would deliver babies who had been gestating for as long as
30 weeks, far longer than the 24-week limit imposed by Pennsylvania law.
Gosnell or staff members would gouge the infant's neck with scissors to
sever the spinal cord, according to the grand jury report. Gosnell
referred to the method as "snipping."
These and other appalling details of the Gosnell trial elicit reactions
that might be called revulsion or disgust or horror. The word that
eminent bioethicist and physician Leon Kass prefers is "repugnance."
This intense human reaction reflects a sort of deep moral intuition, he
says, and it is one that deserves much more serious consideration than
our too-sophisticated culture allows.
******
Degradation and its opposite, human dignity, are central elements of
Dr. Kass's philosophy, and he fears that American society risks becoming
disrespectful of dignity and indifferent to degradation.
Consider abortion. After years of calling for abortions that are
"safe, legal and rare," the Democratic Party in its 2012 platform
dropped such language altogether in an attempt to appeal to its feminist
base. But viewing childbearing solely as a matter of personal
reproductive choice, Dr. Kass says, "means we no longer see a child as a
gift but as a product of our will to be had by choice only. That makes
human choice the basis of all value"—at the price of the child, for "he
or she comes from the hands of nature."
******
The idea that materialism "can cure men of the fear of God and the
fear of death," as Dr. Kass puts it, is at least as old as ancient
Greece. But today it has become especially potent thanks to "the new
genetics, which bore more deeply than ever before into the molecular
basis of living processes." Then there is the rise of neuroscience and
evolutionary psychology, which purport to explain "absolutely everything
about human life" in materialistic terms.
Take the concept of human dignity. In a 2008 essay highly critical of
Dr. Kass's work on the Bush bioethics council, the Harvard psychologist
Steven Pinker questioned the value of dignity as a moral guide.
"Dignity is a phenomenon of human perception," Mr. Pinker wrote.
"Certain signals in the world trigger an attribution in the perceiver."
The perception of human dignity, Mr. Pinker went on, is no different
from how "converging lines in a drawing are a cue for the perception of
depth."
That such an outlook is both blinkered and dangerous, Dr. Kass
thinks, should be obvious to anyone who has ever been in love or felt
other great emotions. "There's no doubt that the human experience of
love," he says, is mirrored by "events that are measurable in the brain.
But anybody who has ever fallen in love knows that love is not just an
elevated level of some peptide in the hypothalamus."
Nor are degradation and dignity. The
Gosnell trial and the terrorist attack at the Boston Marathon have
degradation written all over them. As for dignity, Dr. Kass says, "You
see it in the way nurses treat people who come in for chemotherapy. You
see it in the way a great hostess treats a handicapped guest, helping
him without causing him embarrassment. You see it in the way people come
close to where there is human suffering and are not put off by the
horror but do what is humanly necessary."
Recent Comments